The big dilemma in my life at present is hardly a matter of life or death. In truth, it's pretty unimportant in the general scheme of things, but I'll admit that it's bugging me slightly, hence my desire to get something down on paper, as I'm doing now. The dilemma in question is this: is the Pop Inn cafe in Redhill better than Poppins? The latter has recently opened. And let's face it, it's been a long time coming. For months, possibly years, Poppins has covered its windows with newspaper and I was beginning to think it would never open in Redhill. I started to wonder if the potential operators, the franchisees no less, had had second thoughts, leaving the franchisor (Poppins Restaurants) to find somebody else, but no, it's now open and I've been there twice. The first time was for a cup of tea and a toasted teacake, allowing me to make my first comparison between the two restaurants: a cup of tea in the Pop Inn (which on the A23 on the outskirts of town heading south) is £1, but it's £1.60 in Poppins (although it's a larger cup). I'm not sure if they sell toasted tea cakes in the Pop Inn.
On Friday (12 April) it was time to visit Poppins for a full-blown meal, although, in the end, I settled for baked beans on toast, a cup of tea and apple pie with custard. Unfortunately, I opted for cold custard, which was a mistake on my part. Next time it'll be warm apple pie and ice cream.
And let me add now that beans on toast doesn't really count as a proper meal, which means I'll be back for something more substantial.
Poppins, it has to be said, is much more comfortable than the Pop Inn, not as basic. There's padded banquette seating, American diner style, and the decor is slightly better, although that might be because it's new and the Pop Inn has been around for a few years.
Both establishments offer good service. Faultless service, in fact. It might have something to do with the familial connection between the two restaurants. I'm not exactly sure what it is, but there definitely is a familial link between the operators of both restaurants.
I guess it would be fair to say that Poppins is a tad more upmarket than the Pop Inn, and that might be the reason behind the slightly higher prices. Perhaps the rents are higher in the centre of town. In terms of menu variety, they are about the same. I've already reviewed the Pop Inn restaurant on these pages, so here's a little bit of information about the Poppins menu.
Breakfasts range in price from £5.50 for a Late Breakfast Special consisting of griddled bacon, fried egg, sausage, fried bread, tomatoes and mushroom; and for £7.80 there's the Inclusive Breakfast (two bacon, sausage, tomatoes, beans and hash browns, two slices of toast, butter and preserves, tea and coffee).
There are jacket potatoes (ranging from £4.80 to £5.80); burgers (from £3.60 to £6.70); omelettes (£5.20 to £7.20); salads (£3.50 to £6.40); main meals (everything from chicken nuggets to pies and, at the top of the pile, a sirloin steak); fish dishes, 'world favourites' – like curry and chips – and a wide range of 'sweet treats' and pancakes, including apple pie and ice cream or custard. There's also a children's menu and a takeaway menu.
And if you think that's more than enough, there's a wide range of snacks – and they look pretty substantial too – plus a range of hot and cold drinks.
There are Poppins outlets all over the UK (including one in my home town of Sutton, Surrey) and I'm sure they're all on a par with the Redhill outlet, which will provide healthy competition for other operators in town, including the M&S cafe and others, although the Piazza in the Belfry has gone, sadly.
I like the Poppins Restaurant in Redhill – I'm back in on Wednesday 17th April. The staff are very good, the portions ample and the general decor is good. It's a cosy place AND there's free WiFi.
And guess what? It's open from 0800hrs to 1700hrs six days a week and from 0900hrs to 1600hrs on Sunday.
Postscript, 20 August 2019: I went to Poppins for lunch today and I must put it on record that the Pop Inn café on the A23 offers far better value. The Pop Inn offers the most amazing chicken fillet baguette for just £3.30 whereas Poppins offers a chicken baguette with mayonnaise for £4.00 – they're chalk and cheese. My advice? Go to the Pop Inn on the A23, it's simply better.
On Friday (12 April) it was time to visit Poppins for a full-blown meal, although, in the end, I settled for baked beans on toast, a cup of tea and apple pie with custard. Unfortunately, I opted for cold custard, which was a mistake on my part. Next time it'll be warm apple pie and ice cream.
 |
| Mug of tea, £1.60, but a big mug! |
Poppins, it has to be said, is much more comfortable than the Pop Inn, not as basic. There's padded banquette seating, American diner style, and the decor is slightly better, although that might be because it's new and the Pop Inn has been around for a few years.
Both establishments offer good service. Faultless service, in fact. It might have something to do with the familial connection between the two restaurants. I'm not exactly sure what it is, but there definitely is a familial link between the operators of both restaurants.
I guess it would be fair to say that Poppins is a tad more upmarket than the Pop Inn, and that might be the reason behind the slightly higher prices. Perhaps the rents are higher in the centre of town. In terms of menu variety, they are about the same. I've already reviewed the Pop Inn restaurant on these pages, so here's a little bit of information about the Poppins menu.
Breakfasts range in price from £5.50 for a Late Breakfast Special consisting of griddled bacon, fried egg, sausage, fried bread, tomatoes and mushroom; and for £7.80 there's the Inclusive Breakfast (two bacon, sausage, tomatoes, beans and hash browns, two slices of toast, butter and preserves, tea and coffee).
There are jacket potatoes (ranging from £4.80 to £5.80); burgers (from £3.60 to £6.70); omelettes (£5.20 to £7.20); salads (£3.50 to £6.40); main meals (everything from chicken nuggets to pies and, at the top of the pile, a sirloin steak); fish dishes, 'world favourites' – like curry and chips – and a wide range of 'sweet treats' and pancakes, including apple pie and ice cream or custard. There's also a children's menu and a takeaway menu.
And if you think that's more than enough, there's a wide range of snacks – and they look pretty substantial too – plus a range of hot and cold drinks.
There are Poppins outlets all over the UK (including one in my home town of Sutton, Surrey) and I'm sure they're all on a par with the Redhill outlet, which will provide healthy competition for other operators in town, including the M&S cafe and others, although the Piazza in the Belfry has gone, sadly.
I like the Poppins Restaurant in Redhill – I'm back in on Wednesday 17th April. The staff are very good, the portions ample and the general decor is good. It's a cosy place AND there's free WiFi.
And guess what? It's open from 0800hrs to 1700hrs six days a week and from 0900hrs to 1600hrs on Sunday.
Postscript, 20 August 2019: I went to Poppins for lunch today and I must put it on record that the Pop Inn café on the A23 offers far better value. The Pop Inn offers the most amazing chicken fillet baguette for just £3.30 whereas Poppins offers a chicken baguette with mayonnaise for £4.00 – they're chalk and cheese. My advice? Go to the Pop Inn on the A23, it's simply better.
